Showing posts with label discount brokerage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label discount brokerage. Show all posts

Monday, December 8, 2008

Brokerage Commission Structure Comparison

Below is a comparison between various discount brokerage firms at varying levels of purchase frequencies. While commission fees are a large determinant in which brokerage you might employ, I would encourage you to consider all aspects of a brokerage firm - especially ease of use and customer service - before you give any of them your business. 

If you were to purchase and sell 5 securities a month (10 trades) you would pay:

Zecco - $0
SogoElite - $20
SogoTrade - $30

If you were to purchase and sell 10 securities a month (20 trades) you would pay:

SogoElite - $30
Zecco - $45
SogoTrade - $60

If you were to purchase and sell 15 securities a month (30 trades) you would pay:

SogoElite - $40
Zecco - $90
SogoTrade - $90

If you were to purchase and sell 30 securities a month (60 trades) you would pay:

SogoElite - $70
Just2Trade - $150
SogoTrade - $180
Zecco - $225

Last Updated 12/8/08

Just2Trade

Just2Trade claims that it has "the best pricing in the industry." And at $2.50 per trade, it very well might if you don't trade very often. For $2.50 per trade you get free streaming quotes, an options screener, stock alerts, and most impressive is a free tax preparation software called Maxit - a feature similar to what Zecco offers but at a hefty monthly fee. Additionally, their margin interest rates are very low and their cash balance interest rates are high compared to others in the industry.

You can execute just about any order type as well as no limit or minimum on the number of shares you trade, nor limits on the price of the stock. They offer a trading platform called the "Trading Desk" but you have direct access to the platform from their website; unlike SogoElite's platform.

Just2Trade's Extended Hours trading starts earlier and ends later than SogoElite. The firm offers Extended Hours trading from 7:30a to 9:30a and again from 4p to 8p for an additional fee of $.003 per share. 

Just2Trade has a $2,500 dollar minimum and requires that all applicants have at least 2 years of trading experience. With that said, Just2Trade advises novice traders not to chose them as their brokerage of choice. Something to think about considering they do not offer the bells and whistles that many traders rely upon.

After reading a few other reviews I'm gathering that customer service is not Just2Trade's strong-suit. They offer a discount service and that's exactly what you're getting with multiple day turn-arounds for e-mail inquiries.

Compare Just2Trade to:



Last Updated 12/8/08

Saturday, December 6, 2008

Zecco

Zecco is an online trading brokerage firm that gives its clients 10 free trades per month with a minimum account balance of $2,500 and charges $4.50 per trade after the 10 free. The feature that interests me that I haven't seen with another brokerage is their ZeccoShare Community - you can compare your return on investment to other members. Nothing like a little healthy competition to get your ROI up!

Another feature I like about Zecco is that they offer candlestick charts, so once you've put together your watchlist you only need your Zecco account to watch the stock at the point of purchase. This makes trading basically a one-step procedure. Other brokerages that offer this same feature are SogoElite, and those that do not are SogoTrade.

Zecco is like many other online brokerages in that they offer Real Time Quotes, a Stock Screener, short sell, buy to cover, sell, and buy orders as well as Options Trading and Mutual Fund orders. In their Premium Tools section they offer Tax Planning tools for a monthly fee of $24.99 that will inevitably make reporting your earnings or losses easier come April (something Just2Trade offers for free). Zecco will also monitor your portfolio's performance using typical reporting methods or your own parameters. 

Their trading center is great in that it puts the most important function in clear view - once you click the "Trading" tab you'll see your holdings at the bottom and right up top are your fields to place an order. Also, whether you're looking at your trading center, history, balance, executions, or quotes page you can place an order with the same transaction panel located at the top of the window.  It's pretty no-nonsense. Somewhat like SogoElite's platform.

Overall I like the young, hip feel of Zecco as well as the layout of the site that makes trading easy. After all, trading is the main goal, right?


Last Updated 12/8/08

Thursday, November 6, 2008

SogoTrade

SogoTrade was my first account that I made my first official trade in! Unlike its sister broker, SogoElite, it allows you to trade through an online interface. There is no need to download a platform to the desktop of your computer. This can be handy if you're away from your own computer and want to check in and buy or sell a few securities. 

I changed from SogoTrade to SogoElite over a year ago because I earned enough capital to short the market (make money as the market falls) and SogoElite's platform allowed me to do that while SogoTrade did not. Based on the demos, it looks like SogoTrade has caught up with the times and supports short sells, a big plus and in my case a huge necessity.

Their rates are $3.00 per trade. They're running a promotion currently that if you sign up for a new account you'll receive 100 free trades with a minimum account balance of $500. Additionally, SogoTrade offers free dividend reinvestment, $100 back (in fees) when you transfer an existing account to SogoTrade, as well as 25 free trades for recommending a friend. 

Something they've recently added that has peaked my interest is their Stock Screener - you can search for stocks that meet certain criteria.  Just at first glance I don't feel it is as customizable as a StockCharts.com stock scan, nevertheless, for a day or swing trader that is a great feature.

I enjoyed my SogoTrade account and don't remember having any significant problems trading. SogoTrade also has a number of customer support methods; video tutorials and demos, a toll free number, 4 separate e-mail support accounts, AND live help - you can instant message a representative and get help right on the spot. One caveat though was that their free charts did not and still do not provide the stock quotes in candlesticks, so I needed to supplement my account with a Stockcharts.com account. Having two windows open was a bit cumbersome compared to the platform in SogoElite, but certainly not a deal breaker. 

I'd definitely recommend SogoTrade for the trader who wants a bit more flexibility in when and where they trade, but I prefer the cheaper fee structure and platform SogoElite provides.

Last Updated 12/8/08

Monday, November 3, 2008

SogoElite

SogoElite is my first choice in brokers. For starters, they're cheap. They're real cheap. They're $2 dollar roundtrip cheap if you trade less than 200 shares at a time. Anything over 200 shares and its $.004 per share to get in and to get out. There's a $10 monthly data charge but you really can't beat this deal if you are a frequent trader. To get a better understanding, the commission schedule is proudly displayed on their home page: elite.sogoinvest.com.

Additionally, it has an easy-to-use platform that you download to your desktop, rather than the online interface most brokers use. I can short sell, buy to cover, buy, sell and execute after hours trades if I feel so inclined. I was a bit leary of the platform at first, but after getting started, I truly can't imagine how I'd operate with out it. Everything I need is there. The way I have it set up I can see monthly charts, daily charts, my watch list, and my currently owned securities all in one neatly organized window with to-the-minute stock quotes. I buy and sell on the spot through the SogoElite platform. I can see when my order was executed and watch its progress as soon as I've purchased it. The only regret is that I cannot see a percentage return on the securities I own - I have to crunch the numbers on my own to see if it's ripe for selling. But that's a minor complaint for sure.

One less-than-minor complaint is that the platform doesn't communicate immediately with the online SogoElite site. My trading activity isn't reflected on the online account history or the account activity panels for 24 hours. Considering I keep a meticulous journal of all my trades this grates on my nerves if I forgot to write down my purchase and sell prices. I have to wait until the next day to journal my wins/losses. Again, there's always a work around - write it down or wait a day. Nevertheless, it is a strange delay.  

SogoElite has a number of customer support methods; video tutorials for every facet of the platform, a toll free number, and 4 separate e-mail support accounts. I find the e-mail support a bit cumbersome as it takes a few hours for a response. That's understandable considering the nature of e-mail, but nevertheless I prefer the toll free number as I rarely have to wait for a customer service representative. Despite it being a discount brokerage firm, I haven't received "discount" service at all. You won't have to worry about getting help after you've signed up for an account. All around, I've been very satisfied with SogoElite and would recommend it to any trader who has at least $2,500 to play with. (If your funds are a bit more limited, try its sister company: sogotrade.com. It has an online interface and a lower minimum.)

FOR MAC USERS:
One caveat which I've found a way around is that the platform is not compatible with Macintosh computers. However, I simply downloaded the Apple Bootcamp which allows me to run a PC on my Mac - at start up you just pick PC or Mac (easy!). If you call and ask customer support, they will tell you that the platform does not work on BootCamp...but it does. They're simply not able to guarantee that it will work but mine has been operating fine for over a year.

Last Updated 12/8/08